Increased productivity and tenderness of meat

Researchers are investigating how to improve the quality of beef produced in Brazil, which could increase industry revenue without expanding breeding area

By Heitor Shimizu, in Lincoln  |  Agência FAPESP– Brazil has the world’s largest commercial beef herd, numbering over 225 million heads of cattle, yet only 20% of Brazil’s production is intended for export. Because of this, beef ranks tenth on the list of products exported by Brazil, after soybeans, iron ore, oil, sugarcane, automobiles, chicken, cellulose, soybean meal and coffee.

Experts suggest that exports could be much larger if Brazilian beef were of a quality similar to that produced in Australia, Argentina or Uruguay. It is in improving the quality of beef cattle that science comes into the picture. In addition to obtaining more tender meat, another goal of research is to improve productivity. To achieve this, genetic improvement techniques are used to breed animals that gain weight more quickly or that better resist disease.

“Brazil is the world’s second largest producer of beef, in an industry whose 2016 revenue exceeded US$ 5 billion. The cost of producing Brazilian beef is one of the lowest in the world, but in order to expand market importance, beef production needs to adapt to the standards established by importers. Among quality concerns, tenderness, the amount and the type of marbling can influence the sensory characteristics and nutritional value of the beef,” said Luciana Correia de Almeida Regitano, a researcher at the Brazilian Agricultural Research Corporation, Livestock Raising Division ­­­– Southeast, and faculty member of the graduate program in Evolutionary Genetics and Molecular Biology at the Federal University of São Carlos (in São Paulo, Brazil).

Regitano explained that in Brazil, over 80% of beef cattle is Nelore. The breed, of the subspecies Bos taurus indicus, originated in India, but it does not produce meat that is as tender as that from breeds like Angus (Bos taurus taurus) that originated in Europe and presents more marbling. “Nelore cattle weigh less and have lower productivity and less tender meat. As a result, their price is lower,” she said.

“An important concern of the beef industry is feed cost for the herd, which can constitute up to 40% of production costs. Increasing feeding efficiency is a way to avoid expanding the area used for cattle breeding, which in Brazil is over 168 million hectares. In other words, greater efficiency has as a much an impact on the cost of production as it does on the environment,” Regitano said during FAPESP Week Nebraska-Texas, which runs through September 22, 2017, in the cities of Lincoln, Nebraska and Lubbock, Texas.

Regitano heads up the FAPESP-funded Thematic Project entitled “Molecular basis of meat quality in Nelore beef cattle”. The research study is a follow-up to a previous study that enabled the identification of genomic areas associated with the beef’s production and quality characteristics.

“We initially bred approximately 800 animals for three years on five farms, from birth to slaughter, measuring the phenotypic characteristics such as growth, production, meat quality and feed efficiency. We also collected samples of DNA and subjected them to high density genotyping to determine specific mutations that cover the whole genome. We analyzed more than 700,000 specific mutations dispersed throughout the genome, which provided us with data on the segregation of chromosomal segments,” she said.

“In 2012, we had another project approved by FAPESP that allowed us to expand the initial study and analyze tissue samples to determine the complete sequence of messenger RNAs and all microRNAs found in the tissue. MicroRNAs are small RNA molecules that modulate how messenger RNAs will be translated into proteins,” Regitano explained. The proteins from the tissue samples collected were also analyzed.

“We were able to obtain a data set on 45 different phenotypes and sequenced the messenger RNA and microRNA of 200 muscle samples and 30 liver samples, in addition to analyzing proteins from 65 muscle samples. With support from the CNPq, we were also able to sequence the complete genome, each nucleotide of the genome, of 20 animals. This provided a very important set of data from which we have obtained multiple layers of genomic information on a single animal,” she said.

Genomic tools

“Among the objectives of our current study are complementing the analyses of genomic association to include new phenotypes, integrating the analyses of the functional genome (RNA, microRNA and proteins), assessing the significance of the copy number variation (CNV) and training human resources in the fields of bioinformatics and genomics,” Regitano explained.

Copy number variation is defined as a type of genomic structural variation that includes amplifications and losses of a specific region, which could involve and possibly be one or more complete genes. “We are studying how these alterations could influence the expression of all the genes expressed in muscle as well as the phenotypes assessed,” the researcher asserted.

The richness of the data obtained led to the publication of a series of articles that are expanding knowledge of the possibilities for using genomic tools that can lead to gains in quality and productivity in beef production.

In July 2017, in an article published in the journal BMC Genomics, Regitano and her group identified genes, metabolic pathways and biological processes involved in the differentiation, proliferation, protein conversion, hypertrophy and synthesis of lipids related to the area of the loin eye, a measurement that correlates with the muscularity of the animal and the thickness of its subcutaneous fat, both characteristics that have a direct impact on carcass quality and productivity.

The results of the research point to molecular processes related to the deposit of muscles and fat, which are economically important characteristics for beef production.

In another article, published in the journal PLOS ONE in 2016, Regitano and her colleagues described a broad genomic analysis of CNVs obtained from 723 bulls. The researchers identified 2,600 regions that represent nearly 6.5% of the complete genome of the animals.

The results represented the first comprehensive study of the copy number variations of Nelore cattle, with the identification of regions in which genetic alterations could have important implications in breeding animals whose meat is more tender, thus improving its potential for export and higher prices.